New York · 2026 list
10 Best Candy Shops in New York (2026 List)
Out of 178 candy shops we track in New York, these 10 have the strongest weighted Google ratings right now, led by lil sweet treat in New York at 5.0. The picks span New York, Somers, Rochester, Staten Island and Warwick and more.
Want the full list instead of the top 10? See all 289 chocolate shops in New York, ranked and filterable by city.
Advertisement
At a glance
| # | Shop | City | Rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | lil sweet treat | New York | 5.0 | 735 |
| 2 | Sweetie's Candy NYC | New York | 5.0 | 164 |
| 3 | Frannie's Goodie Shop | Somers | 5.0 | 159 |
| 4 | Brighton Honey | Rochester | 5.0 | 109 |
| 5 | Andy's Candy Cart | Staten Island | 5.0 | 61 |
| 6 | Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge | New York | 4.9 | 315 |
| 7 | Candy Apple Shoppe | Warwick | 4.9 | 260 |
| 8 | Candy Kraft | Altamont | 4.9 | 208 |
| 9 | Chocolate House Brooklyn | Brooklyn | 4.9 | 183 |
| 10 | Mike's Homemade Candies | West Seneca | 4.9 | 181 |
The list
-
lil sweet treat leads the list with a 5.0 average from 735 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to candy. 98% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 8 PM daily.
- Phone
- Not listed
- Website
- lilsweettreat.com
- Hours
- Mon to Sun 11 AM to 8 PM
-
Close behind is Sweetie's Candy NYC with a 5.0 average from 164 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to candy and ice cream. 99% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 11 PM daily.
- Phone
- +1 212-256-0008
- Website
- instagram.com
- Hours
- Mon to Sun 11 AM to 11 PM
-
At number 3 is Frannie's Goodie Shop with a 5.0 average from 159 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to candy and ice cream. 99% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 10 PM on Fridays.
- Phone
- +1 914-617-9147
- Website
- franniesgoodieshopmk.com
- Hours
- Mon to Thu 12 to 9 PMFri to Sat 12 to 10 PMSun 12 to 9 PM
-
Next up is Brighton Honey with a 5.0 average from 109 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to candy. 99% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 7 PM daily.
- Phone
- +1 585-376-0930
- Website
- brightonhoney.com
- Hours
- Mon to Fri 5 to 7 PMSat to Sun 6 AM to 7 PM
-
Andy's Candy Cart comes in at number 5 with a 5.0 average from 61 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to candy. 98% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Sundays.
- Phone
- Not listed
- Website
- Not listed
- Hours
- Mon to Sat 10 AM to 6 PMSun Closed
-
Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge holds its place here with a 4.9 average from 315 reviews on Google. Google describes it as: "Traditional store selling chocolates, confections & fudge, as well as original recipe ice cream." Its Google category points to fudge, candy and ice cream. 97% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 2 AM on Fridays.
- Phone
- +1 212-500-0108
- Website
- kilwins.com
- Hours
- Mon to Thu 10 AM to 12 AMFri to Sat 10 AM to 2 AMSun 10 AM to 12 AM
-
Close behind is Candy Apple Shoppe with a 4.9 average from 260 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to artisan, candy and gifts. 93% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Mondays.
- Phone
- +1 845-986-0089
- Website
- candyappleshoppe.com
- Hours
- Mon ClosedTue to Fri 11 AM to 6 PMSat 10 AM to 6 PMSun 10 AM to 5 PM
-
At number 8 is Candy Kraft with a 4.9 average from 208 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to candy. 95% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Sundays.
- Phone
- +1 518-355-1860
- Website
- candykraft.com
- Hours
- Mon to Fri 10 AM to 6 PMSat 10 AM to 4 PMSun Closed
-
Next up is Chocolate House Brooklyn with a 4.9 average from 183 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to candy. 94% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 1 AM on Fridays.
- Phone
- +1 347-702-1996
- Website
- chocolatehouseus.com
- Hours
- Mon to Thu 2 PM to 12 AMFri to Sat 2 PM to 1 AMSun 2 PM to 12 AM
-
Mike's Homemade Candies comes in at number 10 with a 4.9 average from 181 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to candy. 93% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Sundays.
- Phone
- +1 716-826-6515
- Website
- mikescandies.com
- Hours
- Mon to Tue 10 AM to 6 PMWed 10 AM to 4 PMThu to Fri 10 AM to 6 PMSat 10 AM to 3 PMSun Closed
How we picked these
Every shop here comes from public Google business data, and qualifies because their Google category or description points to candy or confectionery. We rank by weighted rating so a handful of five-star reviews cannot outrank years of consistent ones.
Hours and phone numbers come straight from each listing, and anything missing is marked as missing.
Questions
What is the best candy shop in New York?
lil sweet treat in New York tops this list with a 5.0 average from 735 Google reviews.
How was this list ranked?
By a weighted Google rating: each shop's average is pulled toward the overall average until it has enough reviews to stand on its own. A shop qualifies when their Google category or description points to candy or confectionery. No business pays to appear.
Where can I see every candy shop in New York?
The New York chocolate shop directory lists all 289 shops we track there, with filters, a city breakdown and an open-now toggle.